Why Motivating People Doesn’t Work… and What Does: The New Science of Leading, Energizing, and Engaging by Susan Fowler is a revolutionary book that challenges traditional notions of motivation and offers a fresh perspective on how to truly energize and engage people. Below are 20 lessons from the book:
Read: Get It Done
1. Understanding the Flaws of Traditional Motivation
- Why Traditional Motivation Fails: Fowler argues that traditional motivation techniques, such as rewards and punishments, are often ineffective. They may produce short-term results but fail to create lasting change or genuine engagement. This lesson highlights the need to shift from external motivators to fostering internal motivation.
2. The Science of Motivation: Self-Determination Theory
- Self-Determination Theory (SDT) as a Foundation: The book is heavily based on Self-Determination Theory, which suggests that true motivation comes from satisfying three core psychological needs: autonomy, relatedness, and competence. Understanding SDT is crucial for leaders who want to create environments that support genuine motivation.
3. The Importance of Autonomy
- Empowering People with Autonomy: Autonomy is the feeling of being in control of one’s own actions and decisions. Fowler emphasizes that when people have a sense of autonomy, they are more likely to feel motivated and engaged. Leaders should focus on creating opportunities for people to make choices and have a say in their work.
4. The Role of Relatedness in Motivation
- Fostering Connections and Relatedness: Relatedness refers to the need to feel connected to others and to have a sense of belonging. Fowler highlights the importance of creating a supportive and inclusive work environment where individuals feel valued and connected to their peers and leaders.
5. Competence as a Driver of Motivation
- Building Competence through Mastery: Competence is the need to feel effective and capable in one’s activities. The book stresses the importance of providing opportunities for skill development, feedback, and growth to help individuals build their competence and feel more motivated.
6. The Pitfalls of External Rewards and Punishments
- Why External Incentives Can Backfire: Fowler explains that relying on external rewards (like bonuses or prizes) and punishments (like threats or penalties) can undermine intrinsic motivation. These external motivators can lead to compliance rather than genuine engagement, reducing creativity and innovation.
7. The Spectrum of Motivation: Moving from Suboptimal to Optimal
- Understanding the Spectrum of Motivation: Fowler introduces a spectrum of motivation, ranging from suboptimal (external motivators) to optimal (internal motivators). Leaders should aim to move people along this spectrum towards more sustainable, internal sources of motivation.
8. The Role of Choice in Enhancing Motivation
- Providing Choice and Flexibility: The book underscores the importance of offering choices to enhance motivation. When people feel that they have options and can make decisions about their work, they are more likely to feel motivated and committed.
9. Creating a Sense of Purpose
- Linking Work to a Larger Purpose: Fowler emphasizes the importance of helping people find meaning in their work by connecting it to a larger purpose. When individuals understand how their work contributes to the greater good or aligns with their personal values, they are more likely to feel motivated.
10. Building a Culture of Trust and Respect
- Fostering Trust in the Workplace: Trust and respect are foundational to motivation. Fowler advocates for building a workplace culture where trust is prioritized, and individuals feel respected and valued for their contributions.
11. The Power of Positive Feedback
- Using Feedback to Enhance Competence: Positive feedback is essential for building competence and motivation. Fowler encourages leaders to provide constructive and positive feedback that helps individuals recognize their strengths and areas for growth.
12. Understanding the Difference between Motivation and Engagement
- Differentiating Motivation from Engagement: The book clarifies that while motivation is the drive to take action, engagement is the emotional and intellectual commitment to the work. Leaders need to foster both to create a thriving workplace.
13. Sustaining Motivation through Continuous Learning
- Promoting Lifelong Learning and Growth: Continuous learning is a key factor in sustaining motivation. Fowler advocates for creating opportunities for ongoing education, skill development, and personal growth within the workplace.
14. The Impact of Leadership on Motivation
- Leadership’s Role in Shaping Motivation: Leaders play a crucial role in shaping the motivational climate of an organization. Fowler emphasizes the importance of leadership practices that align with SDT, such as supporting autonomy, fostering relatedness, and building competence.
15. Motivation through Collaboration and Teamwork
- Enhancing Motivation with Collaborative Efforts: Collaboration and teamwork can significantly enhance motivation by fulfilling the need for relatedness. Fowler suggests creating opportunities for collaboration to build stronger connections and a sense of shared purpose.
16. The Importance of Mindfulness in Leadership
- Incorporating Mindfulness to Enhance Motivation: Mindfulness practices can help leaders become more aware of their own motivations and those of their team members. Fowler encourages leaders to practice mindfulness to create a more motivated and engaged workforce.
17. Creating a Motivational Ecosystem
- Building an Environment that Supports Motivation: The book advocates for creating a “motivational ecosystem” where the physical, social, and organizational environment supports and enhances motivation. This includes everything from workspace design to company policies that align with the principles of SDT.
18. The Role of Communication in Motivation
- Effective Communication as a Motivational Tool: Clear, open, and honest communication is essential for building trust and supporting motivation. Fowler emphasizes the importance of transparent communication in creating a motivated and engaged workforce.
19. The Long-Term Benefits of Optimal Motivation
- Sustainable Motivation Leads to Long-Term Success: The book highlights that optimal motivation not only improves immediate performance but also contributes to long-term success and well-being. By fostering intrinsic motivation, organizations can achieve sustained success and employee satisfaction.
20. Practical Strategies for Implementing Optimal Motivation
- Actionable Steps for Leaders: Fowler provides practical strategies for leaders to implement the principles of optimal motivation in their organizations. These strategies include offering choices, providing meaningful feedback, and creating a sense of purpose, all of which contribute to a more motivated and engaged workforce.
Conclusion
Why Motivating People Doesn’t Work… and What Does by Susan Fowler offers a paradigm shift in understanding motivation. The book emphasizes the importance of intrinsic motivation, grounded in autonomy, relatedness, and competence, as the foundation for true engagement and long-term success. By moving away from outdated external motivators and embracing the principles of Self-Determination Theory, leaders can create a more energized, committed, and thriving workplace. These lessons provide a comprehensive guide for leaders seeking to enhance motivation and drive sustainable success in their organizations (Amazon).
